Lou Reed — Intro/Sweet Jane
Album: Rock N Roll AnimalAvg rating:
Your rating:
Total ratings: 3876
Length: 7:55
Plays (last 30 days): 0
share
tweet
Standing on the corner
Suitcase in my hand
Jack's in his corset, Jane is in her vest
Me, honey, I'm in a rock 'n' roll band
Ridin' in a Stutz Bearcat, Jim
You know those were different times
All, all the poets they studied rules of verse
And those ladies they rolled their eyes
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Jack, he is a banker
And Jane, she is a clerk
And Both of them save their money
When they come home from work
Sittin' down by the fire
Radio does play, look classical music there, kids
"The March Of The Wooden Soldiers"
You can hear Jack say
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Some people like to go out dancing
And other people like us, we gotta work
And there's even some evil mothers
They're gonna tell you that everything is just dirt
And you know that women never really faint
And that villains always blink their eyes
That children are the only ones who blush
And that life is just to die
Anyone who ever had a heart
And wouldn't turn around and break it
Anyone who ever played a part
And wouldn't turn around and hate it
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, oh honey, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, oh, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, Sweet Jane
Suitcase in my hand
Jack's in his corset, Jane is in her vest
Me, honey, I'm in a rock 'n' roll band
Ridin' in a Stutz Bearcat, Jim
You know those were different times
All, all the poets they studied rules of verse
And those ladies they rolled their eyes
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Jack, he is a banker
And Jane, she is a clerk
And Both of them save their money
When they come home from work
Sittin' down by the fire
Radio does play, look classical music there, kids
"The March Of The Wooden Soldiers"
You can hear Jack say
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Some people like to go out dancing
And other people like us, we gotta work
And there's even some evil mothers
They're gonna tell you that everything is just dirt
And you know that women never really faint
And that villains always blink their eyes
That children are the only ones who blush
And that life is just to die
Anyone who ever had a heart
And wouldn't turn around and break it
Anyone who ever played a part
And wouldn't turn around and hate it
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, oh honey, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, oh, Sweet Jane
Sweet Jane, Sweet Jane
Comments (500)add comment
che_cavolo wrote:
You can't forget the other half of the guitar duo- Dick Wagner.
The 'Intro' is probably one of the best instrumental rock guitar tunes ever, was written by Steve Hunter who played lead on the fantastic Mitch Ryder 'Detroit' album and did stints with Alice Cooper. The guy influenced a lot of rock music in the 70's from behind the scenes as a session player.
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
You can't forget the other half of the guitar duo- Dick Wagner.
Raised my 9 to 10
kraghh wrote:
Well, c'mon, spit out the other 4! :)
Yeah spill!
Well, c'mon, spit out the other 4! :)
Yeah spill!
memoryboxer wrote:
A Stanley Steamer!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
The Intro always feels/sounds like a 'Shakedown Street' era Dead jam to me. 
This is not a complaint.
And could you choose a more obscure automobile choice than a Stutz Bearcat?!
This is not a complaint.And could you choose a more obscure automobile choice than a Stutz Bearcat?!
A Stanley Steamer!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/...
below72 wrote:
Well, c'mon, spit out the other 4! :)
One of the five greatest introductions/preludes to a rock song of all time. STELLAR!
Well, c'mon, spit out the other 4! :)
The Intro always feels/sounds like a 'Shakedown Street' era Dead jam to me. This is not a complaint.
And could you choose a more obscure automobile choice than a Stutz Bearcat?!
This is not a complaint.And could you choose a more obscure automobile choice than a Stutz Bearcat?!
Fabulous track with outstanding guitar playing. Those guys were so tight they must have been telepathic!
the intro makes it for me.
"LOU!!!"
"LOU!!!"
DW4554 wrote:
I think I was there, ear drums have never recovered...
Masterful intro. Lou was a lucky man to have a band of this caliber, basically borrowed Alice Cooper's band. Saw them live once in Portland, OR. Front of house guy didn't have a clue. Waay too loud even with quality earplugs. When the band is that good the mix is more important than volume. Otherwise amazing performance.
I think I was there, ear drums have never recovered...
It really doesn’t get much better than this! The gnarly and raunchy guitars carry this one from intro to the very last note.
msbolton wrote:
Bass player's getting in some good licks, too.
...two guitars - Steve Hunter and Dick Wagner - well done sirs!
Bass player's getting in some good licks, too.
msbolton wrote:
...two guitars - Steve Hunter and Dick Wagner - well done sirs!
I Agree Completely!
...two guitars - Steve Hunter and Dick Wagner - well done sirs!
I Agree Completely!
Clark_Novato wrote:
NO ONE does this song like Concrete Blond. It was made for them.
Gotta say – I find the studio version on Loaded much more compelling. Sure the live version has some good guitar riffs, but I actually think they distract from the essential groove found in the original. And Lou's vocals on the original are grittier and better recorded. I know it's not an either/or, but it's human nature to compare.
NO ONE does this song like Concrete Blond. It was made for them.
Gotta say – I find the studio version on Loaded much more compelling. Sure the live version has some good guitar riffs, but I actually think they distract from the essential groove found in the original. And Lou's vocals on the original are grittier and better recorded. I know it's not an either/or, but it's human nature to compare.
gbt wrote:
...two guitars - Steve Hunter and Dick Wagner - well done sirs!
sweet sweet guitar, well done sir!
...two guitars - Steve Hunter and Dick Wagner - well done sirs!
thewiseking wrote:
When did they change the name of the Academy of Music to the Palladium? Great venue, I saw saw some fine shows there.
THIS is what the 70s sounded like in My Home Town. Captured Live at the Academy of Music on 14th Street
When did they change the name of the Academy of Music to the Palladium? Great venue, I saw saw some fine shows there.
THIS is what the 70s sounded like in My Home Town. Captured Live at the Academy of Music on 14th Street
SUPER EXCELLENT!! It brings back a LOT of memories! ...But, I do not believe it is the best of anything. That being said, there is a lot of competition out there! I bought this album, right after it was released, I was 19yrs old. I still love it & listen to it a LOT!
Enjoy it!! If you think that is the best guitar solo, intro, or live album, I would NOT be the one to argue with you. Once again, enjoy it and love it for whatever reason! PS: I gave it a TEN!
Enjoy it!! If you think that is the best guitar solo, intro, or live album, I would NOT be the one to argue with you. Once again, enjoy it and love it for whatever reason! PS: I gave it a TEN!
acferrad wrote:
Absolutely not. In the Lou world, listen to the Velvet's "Live in 69" or my fave, Lou's "Take No Prisoners."
The greatest live album of all time!
Absolutely not. In the Lou world, listen to the Velvet's "Live in 69" or my fave, Lou's "Take No Prisoners."
sweet sweet guitar, well done sir!
jasonasonier wrote:
this made me laugh out loud. Thanks for the chuckle
Just learning that the Cowboy Junkies version is a cover 
this made me laugh out loud. Thanks for the chuckle
Genius 10 plus,Lou rocks ✌️
Just learning that the Cowboy Junkies version is a cover
this is cool man, ya
what else .... GODLIKE!!! ICONIC!!!
Lord how I love music like this - always have always will.
Take me back as much of the new music today doesn’t do much for me. Maybe not looking in right places.
PS do like Avalanches
Q: Is anyone better at Rock n Roll than Lou Reed?
A: What a stupid question to ask! Of course not.
A: What a stupid question to ask! Of course not.
I often think "Sweet Jane" is the greatest rock & roll song ever.
But I sometimes think the same thing about "Gimme Shelter."
And occasionally the same thing about another 134 songs...
But I sometimes think the same thing about "Gimme Shelter."
And occasionally the same thing about another 134 songs...
There are a handful of songs that I think I could listen to at least once a day for the rest of my life and never tire of them. This is one. One of my few 10s.
Jelani wrote:
Stunning, really? I think the bassist outdoes the guitar.
BOTH GREAT!!!!!
Stunning, really? I think the bassist outdoes the guitar.
BOTH GREAT!!!!!
The only "10" I've given so far....
S U B L I M E !!!
The greatest live album of all time!
Great segue from Henry Mancini's Pink Panther! Thank You RP!!
che_cavolo wrote:
The finale of "Intro" still gives me goosebumps
The 'Intro' is probably one of the best instrumental rock guitar tunes ever, was written by Steve Hunter who played lead on the fantastic Mitch Ryder 'Detroit' album and did stints with Alice Cooper. The guy influenced a lot of rock music in the 70's from behind the scenes as a session player.
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
The finale of "Intro" still gives me goosebumps
GREAT!!! ICONIC TUNE!!!! Great guitar riff & bass line!
seweitz5453 wrote:
Stunning, really? I think the bassist outdoes the guitar.
Stunning guitar work. This never gets old.
Stunning, really? I think the bassist outdoes the guitar.
My Flying Spaghetti Monster, do these guys suck!
eileenomurphy wrote:
RIGHT ON !!!!!!!!!!
Best "intro" ever!!
RIGHT ON !!!!!!!!!!
Best "intro" ever!!
bdwhitepm wrote:
Thanks for the recommendation!
Just saw the Documentary called Bowie, Iggy and Lou. Fascinating the relationship between the 3 at a critical time in their careers. Highly suggest it if you are a fan of any of them.
I think of this version with the Intro as the best recording of this song
Thanks for the recommendation!
seweitz5453 wrote:
RIGHT ON !!!!!!!!!!
Stunning guitar work. This never gets old.
RIGHT ON !!!!!!!!!!
bdwhitepm wrote:
There is a small cheer when Lou walks out and then a bigger cheer when they recognize the opening tune! or maybe the other way around? still the best version of this tune though!
There is a small cheer when Lou walks out and then a bigger cheer when they recognize the opening tune! or maybe the other way around? still the best version of this tune though!
3Chords wrote:
You are correct!
There is a small cheer when lou walks out and then a bigger cheer when they recognize the opening tune!
You are correct!
There is a small cheer when lou walks out and then a bigger cheer when they recognize the opening tune!
kingart wrote:
Well, ZZ Top is ZZ Top. Seen 'em about 12 times I guess. No need to compare them with anybody.
Charlie from New Hampshire, that woodsy know it all dweeb, blasted Sweet Jane and Rock and Roll Animal in our Boston dorm. I thought I knew better and countered with ZZ Top and Bachman Turner Overdrive. Now that 39 years have passed, Charlie, I have to admit that you had better taste than I.
Well, ZZ Top is ZZ Top. Seen 'em about 12 times I guess. No need to compare them with anybody.
Stunning guitar work. This never gets old.
horseplayer wrote:
I was always under the impression that this is the opening song of the show and Lou is not yet on stage while the band is playing the intro. As they transition into the song, Lou walks out and that's when the crowd cheers.
Am I wrong about that?
You are correct!
I was always under the impression that this is the opening song of the show and Lou is not yet on stage while the band is playing the intro. As they transition into the song, Lou walks out and that's when the crowd cheers.
Am I wrong about that?
You are correct!
Damn - Rock and Roll at it's finest
xcranky_yankee wrote:
I was always under the impression that this is the opening song of the show and Lou is not yet on stage while the band is playing the intro. As they transition into the song, Lou walks out and that's when the crowd cheers.
Am I wrong about that?
always cracks me up that halfway through the tune the audience seems to wake up and say "hey, I know this song!" and start to cheer...as if the intro never happened!
I was always under the impression that this is the opening song of the show and Lou is not yet on stage while the band is playing the intro. As they transition into the song, Lou walks out and that's when the crowd cheers.
Am I wrong about that?
Some of the finest guitar playing I have heard. Hunter and Wagner just crush it.
Wow.
Wow.
the greatest live album of all time
When people ask me what my favorite song is, this is the one. The intro and the ending have to be cranked up.
always cracks me up that halfway through the tune the audience seems to wake up and say "hey, I know this song!" and start to cheer...as if the intro never happened!
egads
he"s just an animal
he"s just an animal
Pink Panther theme, then this. Because RP reasons.
This is a stunningly good tune. Such amazing energy from a pretty laid-back riff. Lou Reed is one of a kind. 1-5-4-4-6-5-1-1. So good.
Eleventy-eleven
One of the best radio. Thanks for perfectely chosen music. Greetings from Ukraine
Dammit, I need to go to lunch; but am stuck at my desk until this exceptional piece of music is through.
One of the best shows I've ever attended...this record played straight through, pure professional artistry and front row seats to boot. Not bragging, just a fantastic memory.
Ah, Yes, Lou in his ROCK STAR era, complete with makeup, glam outfits and competent musicians. Who knew he could pull it off
che_cavolo wrote:
Nothing beats an original of a song. It's merely another version.
The 'Intro' is probably one of the best instrumental rock guitar tunes ever, was written by Steve Hunter who played lead on the fantastic Mitch Ryder 'Detroit' album and did stints with Alice Cooper. The guy influenced a lot of rock music in the 70's from behind the scenes as a session player.
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
Nothing beats an original of a song. It's merely another version.
Excellent! Click thru!
As much as I appreciate this, I have to complain.
RP plays 10 Lou Reed songs and 36 Counting Crows songs.
That is f--ked up!
RP plays 10 Lou Reed songs and 36 Counting Crows songs.
That is f--ked up!
Irresistible air guitar.
I've been listening to RP for years. But hearing this song made me finally pony up and pay for this station. That was a couple of years ago. Always great music.
TIL Lou Reed was not a Brit.. huh.. I always thought he was..
Masterful intro. Lou was a lucky man to have a band of this caliber, basically borrowed Alice Cooper's band. Saw them live once in Portland, OR. Front of house guy didn't have a clue. Waay too loud even with quality earplugs. When the band is that good the mix is more important than volume. Otherwise amazing performance.
Just saw the Documentary called Bowie, Iggy and Lou. Fascinating the relationship between the 3 at a critical time in their careers. Highly suggest it if you are a fan of any of them.
I think of this version with the Intro as the best recording of this song
I think of this version with the Intro as the best recording of this song
Elton John...Psych Furs...Blind Boys...Henry Mancini...Lou Reed...awesomely, insanely great mix. It takes a human..RP forever
Iconic song! ...Thanx Bill!
Test
Shaggy27 wrote:
c.
Lou was not a nice human. But he could write some catchy tunes.
I think lots of artists, in any medium, are not particularly nice people. Maybe their demons drive their art?c.
Amazing intro!
jpfueler wrote:
A lot of the "Greats" really couldn't/can't sing, but they use their limited instrument well with their music. To paraphrase Doctor John, "He's at least as bad as a lot of these others, so why not?"
Lou works alright for me. He was telling stories. He told them well.
Tom Waits. But oh, can he phrase.
A lot of the "Greats" really couldn't/can't sing, but they use their limited instrument well with their music. To paraphrase Doctor John, "He's at least as bad as a lot of these others, so why not?"
Lou works alright for me. He was telling stories. He told them well.
Tom Waits. But oh, can he phrase.
bam23 wrote:
A lot of the "Greats" really couldn't/can't sing, but they use their limited instrument well with their music. To paraphrase Doctor John, "He's at least as bad as a lot of these others, so why not?"
Lou works alright for me. He was telling stories. He told them well.
What a mellifluous voice. Well, not really. People can complain all they want about the singing voice of Jerry Garcia (sure, he wandered off key more than a few times and at times should have let his voice rest for an extended vacation), but Lou Reed could not sing. Period. I understand that there are those who love this, but at times it seems pretty clear that he was scarcely even trying. Oh well.
A lot of the "Greats" really couldn't/can't sing, but they use their limited instrument well with their music. To paraphrase Doctor John, "He's at least as bad as a lot of these others, so why not?"
Lou works alright for me. He was telling stories. He told them well.
great times. Some of them not high as a kite.
slates13 wrote:
Yeah...I get that methodology....and I'm not sure how I have a 6 rating on this one....+3 to 9.
And funny story about mixing up Lou's, my wife has for years told people that Lou Rawls was one of my favorites though she meant Lou Reed...wasn't until this Lou's death in 2013 that she finally understood (Lou Rawls is good too lol) LLRP!!
Just upped my rating to a 10. I only give 10s to those classic songs that are not only great musically, but also great influencers for future rockers!
Yeah...I get that methodology....and I'm not sure how I have a 6 rating on this one....+3 to 9.
And funny story about mixing up Lou's, my wife has for years told people that Lou Rawls was one of my favorites though she meant Lou Reed...wasn't until this Lou's death in 2013 that she finally understood (Lou Rawls is good too lol) LLRP!!
What a mellifluous voice. Well, not really. People can complain all they want about the singing voice of Jerry Garcia (sure, he wandered off key more than a few times and at times should have let his voice rest for an extended vacation), but Lou Reed could not sing. Period. I understand that there are those who love this, but at times it seems pretty clear that he was scarcely even trying. Oh well.
Just upped my rating to a 10. I only give 10s to those classic songs that are not only great musically, but also great influencers for future rockers!
This song could have done without Lou Reed.
My band has played this version of Sweet Jane a few times. It is a blast!
Holy Cow! The bass player ROCKS!
(... while other people like us gotta work ...)
(... while other people like us gotta work ...)
Hooks?
Who said hooks?
Who said hooks?
Hasn't aged well.
Great memories hanging out
😎Ah the memories of a wasted youth...
che_cavolo wrote:
Agree with the first half of this post.
However, this IS Lou's (and the Velvet Underground's) song and this version is live. Ain't nobodies version ruling over this. How explosive it must have been to be in the building for this, as live recordings (especially from this era) always lose a little something.
Mott's version hews closer to this live version in style than the original Velvet Underground version, which is slower and more sultry, BUT Ian Hunter Patterson's vocals are not nearly as beautiful as Lou's on that studio version.
For apples-to-apples compare these:
Velvet: https://youtu.be/nkumhBVPGdg
Mott: https://youtu.be/79m8FXz7GEE
The 'Intro' is probably one of the best instrumental rock guitar tunes ever, was written by Steve Hunter who played lead on the fantastic Mitch Ryder 'Detroit' album and did stints with Alice Cooper. The guy influenced a lot of rock music in the 70's from behind the scenes as a session player.
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
Agree with the first half of this post.
However, this IS Lou's (and the Velvet Underground's) song and this version is live. Ain't nobodies version ruling over this. How explosive it must have been to be in the building for this, as live recordings (especially from this era) always lose a little something.
Mott's version hews closer to this live version in style than the original Velvet Underground version, which is slower and more sultry, BUT Ian Hunter Patterson's vocals are not nearly as beautiful as Lou's on that studio version.
For apples-to-apples compare these:
Velvet: https://youtu.be/nkumhBVPGdg
Mott: https://youtu.be/79m8FXz7GEE
Akazungu wrote:
The Junkies are doing the Live in 69 version. That Live in 69 Velvet Underground album is mind blowing in its greatness.
I must admit I still prefer the Cowboy Junkie's version, but this is still a solid 10.
The Junkies are doing the Live in 69 version. That Live in 69 Velvet Underground album is mind blowing in its greatness.
Shaggy27 wrote:
So fucking what Lou played great music
Lou was not a nice human. But he could write some catchy tunes.
So fucking what Lou played great music
Lou was not a nice human. But he could write some catchy tunes.
one of the greatest intros ever...and love the canned applause effect
18 years old hanging out out in a hippie farm house snow drift road, listening to this song for the first time before walking to the QUEEN VICTORIA HOTEL to watch JOHNNY'S DANCE BAND, a memorable old Victorian hotel located in the countryside South of Allentown, PA. GOD those were the days...
ELEVENTY ELEVEN!
Bumped it to a 10 because of the memories this songs invokes......plus it's just a damn good kickass song especially with that Intro. Cannot imagine what it would have been like to have seen this live.
Wish I had better speaker system connected to computer.
Wish I had better speaker system connected to computer.
danthebeachman wrote:
In my opinion the best version of "Sweet Jane" was done by the Cowboy Junkies"
che_cavolo wrote:
The 'Intro' is probably one of the best instrumental rock guitar tunes ever, was written by Steve Hunter who played lead on the fantastic Mitch Ryder 'Detroit' album and did stints with Alice Cooper. The guy influenced a lot of rock music in the 70's from behind the scenes as a session player.
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
As for the song itself, Mott's version rules...
put the headphones back on and I got this Gem.
deliciously wonderful
rock and roll
Thanks
deliciously wonderful
rock and roll
Thanks
Today - a very good program - until nowNever fails to cause a shiver. Don't think I'll ever tire of hearing this - superb playing throughout the band. VERY high on my all-time favourites list.
A regrettable look. (The music, of course, rocks.)
gjeeg wrote:
The musicians were:
Pentti Glan (drums), Prakash John (bass), Ray Colcord (keyboards), and Dick Wagner and Steve Hunter on guitars.
Have only seen Lou live on video, and many of the performances that were the start of the show, include a build-up
that doesn't include Mr. Reed, who eventually appears to roaring applause.
The Epic cut on this Album is 'Heroin.'
.
.
.
.
.
Little Help..... Who is the MONSTER lineup in the astonishing recording??
(The applause bursts when Lou appears on stage.... Haven't you ever been to a live show?!!)
(The applause bursts when Lou appears on stage.... Haven't you ever been to a live show?!!)
The musicians were:
Pentti Glan (drums), Prakash John (bass), Ray Colcord (keyboards), and Dick Wagner and Steve Hunter on guitars.
Have only seen Lou live on video, and many of the performances that were the start of the show, include a build-up
that doesn't include Mr. Reed, who eventually appears to roaring applause.
The Epic cut on this Album is 'Heroin.'
.
.
.
.
.
Little Help..... Who is the MONSTER lineup in the astonishing recording??
(The applause bursts when Lou appears on stage.... Haven't you ever been to a live show?!!)
(The applause bursts when Lou appears on stage.... Haven't you ever been to a live show?!!)
Bill is on fire tonight... Loving RP
treatment_bound wrote:
Awesome! Were you at the B.L. during the dates of May 17-21, 1978 when "Take No Prisoners" was recorded? According to Wiki, Springsteen showed for at least one of 'em:
I went one of those nights - I'll have to see if I still have the ticket stub to see which night it was. I think the version of "Sweet Jane" from "Take No Prisoners" (where he goes off on rants about Randy Newman and Barbra Streisand) was recorded the night we were there. I didn't see Bruce Springsteen there but Martin Scorcese and Brian DePalma were sitting near us. It was a night where Lou cursed out Clive Davis, who was also in the house.
Awesome! Were you at the B.L. during the dates of May 17-21, 1978 when "Take No Prisoners" was recorded? According to Wiki, Springsteen showed for at least one of 'em:
CD One:
"Sweet Jane" – 10:44"I Wanna Be Black" – 6:27"Satellite of Love" – 7:06"Pale Blue Eyes" – 7:36"Berlin" – 6:13"I'm Waiting for the Man" – 13:59CD Two:
"Coney Island Baby" – 8:37"Street Hassle" – 13:15"Walk on the Wild Side" – 16:54"Leave Me Alone" – 7:29I went one of those nights - I'll have to see if I still have the ticket stub to see which night it was. I think the version of "Sweet Jane" from "Take No Prisoners" (where he goes off on rants about Randy Newman and Barbra Streisand) was recorded the night we were there. I didn't see Bruce Springsteen there but Martin Scorcese and Brian DePalma were sitting near us. It was a night where Lou cursed out Clive Davis, who was also in the house.
Proclivities wrote:
Awesome! Were you at the B.L. during the dates of May 17-21, 1978 when "Take No Prisoners" was recorded? According to Wiki, Springsteen showed for at least one of 'em:
I didn't see Lou Reed until about 1977 or '78, at The Bottom Line; I had to use an older friend's driver's license (pre-photo days fortunately) to get in.
Awesome! Were you at the B.L. during the dates of May 17-21, 1978 when "Take No Prisoners" was recorded? According to Wiki, Springsteen showed for at least one of 'em:
CD One:
CD Two:
"Coney Island Baby" – 8:37"Street Hassle" – 13:15"Walk on the Wild Side" – 16:54"Leave Me Alone" – 7:29Gee, I miss Lou.
you didn't go to 42nd St and buy a cheesey fake ID at one of those tourist t-shirt stores Proclivities?
thats what me and my pals used : P
thats what me and my pals used : P
treatment_bound wrote:
Thanks for solving a mystery I've had for over 40 years.
I guess I'm more impressed you actually know some people who witnessed a Lou Reed show at Howard Stein's Academy of Music (later called The Palladium) on 12/21/73, the night they recorded "Rock 'n' Roll Animal".
I had some older friends who went to that show - some of whom introduced me to the music of the lesser-known, "underground" artists in the mid-1970s. I think my older sister went as well. I didn't see Lou Reed until about 1977 or '78, at The Bottom Line; I had to use an older friend's driver's license (pre-photo days fortunately) to get in. I saw a lot of shows at The Palladium, but none when it was called "The Academy".
Thanks for solving a mystery I've had for over 40 years.
I guess I'm more impressed you actually know some people who witnessed a Lou Reed show at Howard Stein's Academy of Music (later called The Palladium) on 12/21/73, the night they recorded "Rock 'n' Roll Animal".
I had some older friends who went to that show - some of whom introduced me to the music of the lesser-known, "underground" artists in the mid-1970s. I think my older sister went as well. I didn't see Lou Reed until about 1977 or '78, at The Bottom Line; I had to use an older friend's driver's license (pre-photo days fortunately) to get in. I saw a lot of shows at The Palladium, but none when it was called "The Academy".
Proclivities wrote:
Yes, as far as I had been told by a few different people who were at that show: he was off-stage throughout that intro and the increase in applause did occur when he walked out onto the stage.
Thanks for solving a mystery I've had for over 40 years.
I guess I'm more impressed you actually know some people who witnessed a Lou Reed show at Howard Stein's Academy of Music (later called The Palladium) on 12/21/73, the night they recorded "Rock 'n' Roll Animal".
Yes, as far as I had been told by a few different people who were at that show: he was off-stage throughout that intro and the increase in applause did occur when he walked out onto the stage.
Thanks for solving a mystery I've had for over 40 years.
I guess I'm more impressed you actually know some people who witnessed a Lou Reed show at Howard Stein's Academy of Music (later called The Palladium) on 12/21/73, the night they recorded "Rock 'n' Roll Animal".
On_The_Beach wrote:
Yes, as far as I had been told by a few different people who were at that show: he was off-stage throughout that intro and the increase in applause did occur when he walked out onto the stage.
No vocals prior to the applause.
Perhaps they were applauding Lou appearing on stage?
If the applause was dubbed in don't you think they would have put it in at the more obvious spot?
Just speculating, of course.
Perhaps they were applauding Lou appearing on stage?
If the applause was dubbed in don't you think they would have put it in at the more obvious spot?
Just speculating, of course.
Yes, as far as I had been told by a few different people who were at that show: he was off-stage throughout that intro and the increase in applause did occur when he walked out onto the stage.
Good old rock n roll!
treatment_bound wrote:
No vocals prior to the applause.
Perhaps they were applauding Lou appearing on stage?
If the applause was dubbed in don't you think they would have put it in at the more obvious spot?
Just speculating, of course.
Is it wrong to be slightly irked all these years later that the applause is obviously dubbed in?
Why would the entire audience all start clapping at least 10 seconds AFTER the famous riff kicks in at 3:20? It couldn't have colectively taken everyone in attendence that long to figure it out which song was playing.
Why would the entire audience all start clapping at least 10 seconds AFTER the famous riff kicks in at 3:20? It couldn't have colectively taken everyone in attendence that long to figure it out which song was playing.
No vocals prior to the applause.
Perhaps they were applauding Lou appearing on stage?
If the applause was dubbed in don't you think they would have put it in at the more obvious spot?
Just speculating, of course.
Is it wrong to be slightly irked all these years later that the applause is obviously dubbed in?
Why would the entire audience all start clapping at least 10 seconds AFTER the famous riff kicks in at 3:20? It couldn't have collectively taken everyone in attendance that long to figure it out which song was playing.
Why would the entire audience all start clapping at least 10 seconds AFTER the famous riff kicks in at 3:20? It couldn't have collectively taken everyone in attendance that long to figure it out which song was playing.
thewiseking wrote:
That's like preferring Pat Boone to Little Richard
THEY'RE BOTH STILL WITH US, SO YOU COULD CONCEIVABLY CATCH THEM IN THE SAME CONCERT.
BUT WHO WOULD YOU PREFER OPEN?
That's like preferring Pat Boone to Little Richard
THEY'RE BOTH STILL WITH US, SO YOU COULD CONCEIVABLY CATCH THEM IN THE SAME CONCERT.
BUT WHO WOULD YOU PREFER OPEN?
Akazungu wrote:
That's like preferring Pat Boone to Little Richard
I must admit I still prefer the Cowboy Junkie's version, but this is still a solid 10.
That's like preferring Pat Boone to Little Richard
Akazungu wrote:
The numbers don't go to 11, so you must really be splitting some mighty fine hairs.
For my part, the 2 versions are not comparable.
I must admit I still prefer the Cowboy Junkie's version, but this is still a solid 10.
The numbers don't go to 11, so you must really be splitting some mighty fine hairs.
For my part, the 2 versions are not comparable.
But I sometimes think the same thing about "Gimme Shelter."
And occasionally the same thing about another 134 songs...
I know the feeling but this live version shows that Lou couldn't sing worth a damn...