[ ]   [ ]   [ ]                        [ ]      [ ]   [ ]
Stone Temple Pilots — Sour Girl
Album: No. 4
Avg rating:
7.2

Your rating:
Total ratings: 1487









Released: 1999
Length: 4:12
Plays (last 30 days): 0
She turned away
What was she looking at?
She was a sour girl
The day that she met me
Hey! What are you looking at?
She was a happy girl
The day that she left me
She turned away
What was she looking at?
She was a sour girl
The day that she met me
Hey! What are you looking at?
She was a happy girl
When she left me

What would you do?
What would you do
If I followed you?
What would you do
If I follow?

Don't turn away
What are you looking at?
He was so happy on
The day that he met her
Say, what are you looking at?
I was a superman
But looks are deceiving

The rollercoaster
Rides a lonely one
I paid a ransom note
To stop it from steaming
Hey! What are you looking at?
She was a teenage
Girl when she met me

What would you do?
What would you do
If I followed you?
What would you do
If I follow?

What would you do?
(What would you do?)
What would you do
If I followed you?
What would you do
If I follow?

The girl got reasons
They all got reasons

What would you do?
(What would you do?)
What would you do
If I followed you?
What would you do
If I follow?

What would you do?
(What would you do?)
What would you do
If I followed you?
What would you do
If I follow?

Hey! What are you looking at?
She was a happy girl
The day that she left me
The day that she left me
The day that she left me
She was a happy girl
The day that she left me
She was a sour girl
The day that she met
The day that she left me
Comments (180)add comment
I heard this a few times on the radio and it's been floating around in my head for years - I had NO idea it was Stone Temple Pilots. Thought it was just a random pop song.

I really like it. 
 gurke wrote:
Scott Weiland was the greatest frontman of that Grunge years... 


in the top 4 for me. chris, layne, mark lanegan and scott. i'd throw in shawn smith (from brad, twilight singers, etc.) for fun, too. all have very distinctive vocals.
 thurstonvirginia wrote:

Years ago, I read an anecdote, possibly apocryphal, that the original band name was Shirley Temple's Pu**y. The band had to change the name as they gained recognition, but kept the first letters and played around with different words till they came up with Stone Temple Pilots. Anyone else ever heard this story?



yes, i did hear that, too!
Years ago, I read an anecdote, possibly apocryphal, that the original band name was Shirley Temple's Pu**y. The band had to change the name as they gained recognition, but kept the first letters and played around with different words till they came up with Stone Temple Pilots. Anyone else ever heard this story?
 gurke wrote:
Scott Weiland was the greatest frontman of that Grunge years... 


Better than Kurt, Chris, Eddie, or Layne? How exactly are you defining "greatest"?
(Not trying to criticize him, but he's got some stiff competition. Crazy that only one of those four is still alive though.)
Scott Weiland was the greatest frontman of that Grunge years... 
 sirdroseph wrote:


Nope, no, uh uh, actually it doesn't. BTW I like XTC and love STP and I also love this song, but don't see any correlation at all.{#No}


Yes it does. At least the singer's voice does.
Never gets old.
Really like this one. So much better than most of the crap in the STP catalogue
Scott Weiland had a way with a song.
 bb_matt wrote:
Oddly enough, this reminds me *massively* of Joe Jackson. I never thought I'd link STP and Joe, but there you go ...

 
Very interesting, especially given that I'm a *huge* JJ fan, and this is among my favorite STP songs. Hmmm...

I'm a sucker for the back end of each chorus when the lead guitar plays the open string melody. Like a shot of sweet sweet sugar to the brain.
 bb_matt wrote:
Oddly enough, this reminds me *massively* of Joe Jackson. I never thought I'd link STP and Joe, but there you go ...

 
Some agree but I just can't hear Jackson. Nope...but that is the beauty of music, different things for different folks.

so good!
Yes, a great song.
...they all got reasons...

Great song.  Sweet chord progression by Dean DeLeo too.
{#Hearteyes}
Another first for me here on RP. 

And if I had to guess the authors of this tune, no way I'd tag Stone Temple Pilots as the band. This is WAY more pop-y than Vasoline or Creep. THIS is the band in the same genre as Soundgarden and Candlebox? 
 bb_matt wrote:
Oddly enough, this reminds me *massively* of Joe Jackson. I never thought I'd link STP and Joe, but there you go ...

 
I hear it, too. I know there's at least one song (Days Of The Week) where Weiland cited Jackson as an influence.
Such a creative, unconventional song that still manages to set serious ear worms...

Love it! 
RIP Scott


woo hoo{#Music}
My favorite STP song.  
oh I like this one a real lot, quite cool time trip inducing, back when things were more refined and serious and you could actually have real conversations with a stunning young thing at the bar
 bb_matt wrote:

Even people outside your church love it.
 
Everybody in my mushrooming multitude of homeless camps loves this cool song...

hope you be having a marvelous time right this minute, bb_matt... 
 Lazarus wrote:

Everybody in my church loves this cool song...
 

 
Even people outside your church love it.
Oddly enough, this reminds me *massively* of Joe Jackson. I never thought I'd link STP and Joe, but there you go ...
Eh...on the lyrics (4)...great jamming on the band (9)...but still an 8
For the longest time I thought this was a Smithereens song. Just has their melody and guitar riffs. One of the best STP songs for sure.

Everybody in my church loves this cool song...
 
 ick wrote:

Soundgarden, Kyuss, Monster Magnet, Acid King, Acrimony, Orange Goblin, Fu Manchu, Brant Bjork & the Bros, Unida, Slo Burn, Hermano, Mondo Generator and at times Q.O.T.S.A. is who.

 

 

LOL!   .............................


 michaelgmitchell wrote:
Fond memories when this came out. It WAS a tune for the times. Yes, it involved a girl. When doesn't it?
 
Rumours have it that girls like being involved.
Sounds like the singer of the Smithereens.
 terrapin52 wrote:
Cop: This is the most dangerous neighborhood in the city.  What are you doing here?
Weiland: Buying drugs. 
 

love this song.
This is just pure bliss to my ears.....the chords, guitar, chorus, vocals.....EXCELLENT SONG!! {#Angel}
Cop: This is the most dangerous neighborhood in the city.  What are you doing here?
Weiland: Buying drugs. 
Fond memories when this came out. It WAS a tune for the times. Yes, it involved a girl. When doesn't it?

Along with Alice in Chains, the other definitive grunge band of the 90s.{#Yes}Nirvana was not bad and Pearl Jam............well if momma said if you can't say nothing nice............


 Byronape wrote:

Sorry...  Poacher is a dude.  Story just got a little less interesting.
 
Oh I don't know. . . I have excellent Moobs and a beard. 
 Tippster wrote:

Especially if Poacher is female...
 
Sorry...  Poacher is a dude.  Story just got a little less interesting.

 coyotexxx2 wrote:


Sounds like there may be a good story behind that lost shirt. 
 
Especially if Poacher is female...
Scott Weiland
My favorite bad boy crush ... {#Hearteyes}
 Poacher wrote:
I once had a great Stone Temple Pilots t-shirt that I loved.
I lost it at a festival. 
I hope it is happy.
That is all. 
 

Sounds like there may be a good story behind that lost shirt. 
 kcar wrote:
Sounds a bit like a slow XTC song...
Yes, exactly. STP...XTC. I thought it was Andy Partridge singing the first time I spun this one. Much more Beatles-esque than most STP. 


 kcar wrote:
Sounds a bit like a slow XTC song...
 

Nope, no, uh uh, actually it doesn't. BTW I like XTC and love STP and I also love this song, but don't see any correlation at all.{#No}
I once had a great Stone Temple Pilots t-shirt that I loved.
I lost it at a festival. 
I hope it is happy.
That is all. 
Sounds a bit like a slow XTC song...
 westslope wrote:

Yeah, this is a great tune. 

So what's with the name of the band?  Sounds like a bunch of stoners.  Not to say that is necessarily a bad thing.....  But who wants to sound like a "bunch of stoners"?

 
It was pretty mandatory for grunge groups in the early 1990's to "sound like a 'bunch of stoners'".  It's not as if that element has ever been absent from rock music at any time - or even jazz for that matter.  Anyhow, I think this is one of their best tunes - great chord progression, nice melody.
 westslope wrote:

Yeah, this is a great tune.

 

So what's with the name of the band?  Sounds like a bunch of stoners.  Not to say that is necessarily a bad thing.....  But who wants to sound like a "bunch of stoners"?


 
Soundgarden, Kyuss, Monster Magnet, Acid King, Acrimony, Orange Goblin, Fu Manchu, Brant Bjork & the Bros, Unida, Slo Burn, Hermano, Mondo Generator and at times Q.O.T.S.A. is who.

There's an atmosphere to this track that I really like. I believe it's the prodding and consistent melodic bassline...that plays with the melody and harmony of the vocals. I didn't realize that this was Stone Temple Pilots. Doesn't really sound a lot like them...but versatility isn't a bad thing. Haven't heard this tune much which always fares well with me. :)
TOTALLY, THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT ME....
 Stingray wrote:
Not at all their best!
Not that they have much good!
SOUNDS LIKE A BOYGROUP FROM FLORIDA!

I thought they are still in rehab!

NO! NO!! NO!!!
(anything, not that!)

SR

PS
I know 1001 better songs, if my girlfriends come visiting!
If you know what I mean...
 
Y'know, Stingray - I've given up trying to figure you out. I thought you were a troll, but they usually post and run. Then, I thought you were just one of those people who loves to stir up trouble and stick around to keep things festering.

Now, though, I must just be really tired. Every once in awhile, we agree on music, but apart from that, you're an enigma. Not that that's a BAD thing.

Like now.  I agree - this is NOT STP's best work. As for how much "good" work they've produced, I'm not objective at all, having only heard a few of their songs. And I totally disagree about the boygroup from Florida comment!  I've never heard a boygroup from Florida that actually had a guitarist who could do a solo, although I do know a guy from Florida who can play a wicked guitar, sing, and write his own songs.)

Challenge:  List those 1001 better songs - or, for the sake of space, send me a PM with those 1001 songs. I reserve the right to post any or all of your choices, with possible critiques. And, being a woman, I can tell you which songs would work and which wouldn't.

*tock*  Ball's in your court now, buddy. I shall expect a PM from you in the next two weeks. If I don't receive your list of songs, or a valid reason why you can't justify your comments, be prepared to retract your "1001 songs" statement publicly.  And to sweeten the deal, if you renig, you'll owe me ten bucks.  (WAIT! you yell - what's in it for ME?  Well, the fact that I'm willing to make this fun instead of just calling you a troll and ignoring your comments is one benefit.  Another is that how you handle this challenge will determine/change how some folks here in RP-land view you. And, If I happen to get that 1001 song list from you, regardless of whether they're valid songs or not, I'll come back here and vindicate you.)  Have fun! {#Mrgreen}

Not at all their best!
Not that they have much good!
SOUNDS LIKE A BOYGROUP FROM FLORIDA!

I thought they are still in rehab!

NO! NO!! NO!!!
(anything, not that!)

SR

PS
I know 1001 better songs, if my girlfriends come visiting!
If you know what I mean...


love me some STP

Yeah, this is a great tune.

 

So what's with the name of the band?  Sounds like a bunch of stoners.  Not to say that is necessarily a bad thing.....  But who wants to sound like a "bunch of stoners"?


1999 was year of release.....just saying.

Plzzzzzzz,,, play more STP
Haven't heard this one in awhile, yea luv me some STP!{#Cowboy}
I love the STP. This song is great, and their "Purple" album is a classic, in my opinion. Great 90s pop. {#Clap}
Excellent tune.
When these guys first came out, they got zero respect from me or the folks I hung out with at the time (referred to as the Stone Pimple Toilets... we were sooo mature weren't we?).  But... this song completely changed my attitude about STP.  Very innovative song structure and an engaging melody.  I remember it was on "heavy rotation" in my head for several months.
This is a good one. {#Nyah}
I love this song
{#Puke}
 chyk5 wrote:


Thankfully, for me, not another Blur or Pulp. This band is far more original than you give them credit for here.
 
Couldn't agree more! STP were a creative bunch.  I thought Velvet Revolver was too.  Each a distinct and legimate rock band, each with their own sound.

Glad that Velvet Revolver didn't rest on the laurels of their previous lives...very refreshing.

STP had good mojo - I hope for more.

 esotericderek wrote:

They were very good style mimics. STP co-opted grunge quite well, then after grunge pretty much dried up, they went for the Britpop sound that followed it (ironically, a sound intended by Brits to counteract the grunge influence). STP wasn't bad with the Britpop sound, but they were definitely no Blur or Pulp.

 

Thankfully, for me, not another Blur or Pulp. This band is far more original than you give them credit for here.
yes this is great
 esotericderek wrote:

They were very good style mimics. STP co-opted grunge quite well, then after grunge pretty much dried up, they went for the Britpop sound that followed it (ironically, a sound intended by Brits to counteract the grunge influence). STP wasn't bad with the Britpop sound, but they were definitely no Blur or Pulp.


  Excellent spot on comment — Scott and Co are very versatile


 bpkengor wrote:
I don't know. STP songs are like candy to me. they are really good for that few seconds of consumption but then i feel cheated afterward. they just don't have any depth to my ears.

 
Agreed — I do like candy though

Saw them last Wednesday! Scott's still got it. He was running all over the place with his megaphone in hand.
jjbix wrote:
i really stopped and listened to this song & upgraded it to a 7.6 !


...well I downgraded it to a 7.2 ...

westslope wrote:
I like this song. However, dontcha think the first few riffs sound like that George Harrison song... what is it now? Pisces fish maybe.
It also reminds me of that "Ah, Leah" song that was popular in the late 80s.
i really stopped and listened to this song & upgraded it to a 7.6 !
Woo! Touring this summer! VERY excited. These guys are my favorite 90's band.
Where have all the flowers gone ? Long time passing. So Seattle what's next ? It was great while it lasted but you've been asleep now WAY TOO LONG- - -Wake up, Rip Van Grunge !!
I like this song. However, dontcha think the first few riffs sound like that George Harrison song... what is it now? Pisces fish maybe.
doesnt follow madeleine well, but I will always love this band
ArbiterOfGoodTaste wrote:
Never in a million years would I have guessed this was STP. Not bad.
They were very good style mimics. STP co-opted grunge quite well, then after grunge pretty much dried up, they went for the Britpop sound that followed it (ironically, a sound intended by Brits to counteract the grunge influence). STP wasn't bad with the Britpop sound, but they were definitely no Blur or Pulp.
I don't know. STP songs are like candy to me. they are really good for that few seconds of consumption but then i feel cheated afterward. they just don't have any depth to my ears.
Definitely one of their better tunes.. 8/10
ArbiterOfGoodTaste wrote:
Never in a million years would I have guessed this was STP. Not bad.
I agree with R Biter...this is SO not STP, but a great tune... I love being surprised
"What would you do if I followed you?" - report you to the cops as a stalker, you creep!
love this song!
I saw a rerun of an old SNL not long ago...STP did \"Naked Sunday\". Say what you will about Scott Weiland and the band, but it was a most impressive performance.
My favorite STP song everrrrr! *bobs head in time*
horstman wrote:
XTC?
Damn, it nearly is too!
When these guys had it they really had it. This one and \"Big Bang Baby\" are my faves.
Awesome!
turn it up!
I just love this song. Such a cool feel to contrast the lyrics.
Never in a million years would I have guessed this was STP. Not bad.
Hooked by creeper....rythmically wonderful!
maryte wrote:
I get the same kind of feeling from "Pretty Penny" (which I tried uploading but was immediately sorried)...
I tried that one, too. Same result.
fine, fine guitar .... kinda sad song about a doomed relationship which we can most likely all relate to. still quite a song...
love STP! SMG was pretty fine in the video too!
horstman wrote:
XTC?
No just a really, really poor substitution...
Boosiewolf wrote:
This is perhaps my favorite STP song. It just was out of the ordinary from them, and the harmonies were cool. Glad it showed up on RP.
I get the same kind of feeling from "Pretty Penny" (which I tried uploading but was immediately sorried)...
Hannio wrote:
Reminds me a lot of Buffalo Springfield. Maybe that's why I like it so much.
Indeed, it does have that "Rock & Roll Woman" vibe going on...
o.m.g., s.t.p. on r.p....p.f.c.! (pretty fucking cool)
Reminds me a lot of Buffalo Springfield. Maybe that's why I like it so much.
fairy38 wrote:
this song could be alright, but I absolutely can't stand STP, so I can't get over that to enjoy it. I usually like 99% of tunes on RP - but this one makes me turn the volume down :(
I agree 100%. I have always hated this band. Not necessarily any reason -- just a visceral revulsion.
pianocomposer wrote:
(Edited later) "sour" refers to both taste and temperment, so there's both a sexual and a psychological component to what he's saying.
And I totally dig this groove.
XTC?
I totally dig this song. If these guys were less screamy on more of their stuff I'd be happy. But they have enough non-screamy to keep me coming back.
TOO LONG
I love the song, but what the hell are they talking about?
People never realize that the Teletubbies seen in the video are actually Weiland's smack buddies! In all seriousness though, it's a real fine song. It sounds quite druggy, however. It's probably the druggiest sounding record since the Black Crowes "Amorica."
Would someone be so kind to pleeeeeease upload song from the album CORE!!!
Yes, my best taste and pleasure memories are definitely that insatiable sour girl with the great personality.
Oh....Oh...there singing my song!
he has a great voice!
I've a little thing for this song... caught my ear some time ago... ...
Love those lyrics... I'm a sour boy
Boosiewolf wrote:
This is perhaps my favorite STP song. It just was out of the ordinary from them, and the harmonies were cool. Glad it showed up on RP.
This song is about one of the band's girlfriend=turned-wife. She left him, as you can probably tell. He was happy, needless to say, when she left. So was she. I've read that sour girl is also to be taken literally. (Edited later) "sour" refers to both taste and temperment, so there's both a sexual and a psychological component to what he's saying.
Rickvee wrote:
Great song from a criminally underrated band.
I couldn't agree more. I miss STP, but do enjoy Velvet Revolver now.
This is a great song, with a surprisingly melodic vocal.
Great song from a criminally underrated band.
lixy wrote:
Actually it was more around 2000. I do consider them a one-hit band as well. Haven't heard it ever since (it was overplayed at the time on TV music channels at the time). Shows how unprejudicist RP is!
You are aware of their earlier stuff, right? Which "one" is the one hit?