Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 288
Warning: round() expects parameter 2 to be int, float given in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 9
Warning: Division by zero in /var/www/html/rp3-content/Music/song_info.php on line 292
Listener-supported — Commercial-free
share
tweet
Comments (44)add comment
Once I stopped comparing this to Bowie's version I realized I like it, mostly. The background music is very nice but I like that kind of dissonance, particularly with string instruments. Gabriel sounds a bit constrained and, if I tried to describe it, I would say that the vocal track sounds out of balance with the music. Too pronounced.
3>2
Stop it, Peter, stop it. It's okay to cover something, but not to bury it.
Stop it, Peter, stop it. It's okay to cover something, but not to bury it.
No one does this song like Marianne Faithful ... Please, let's just hear Marianne's Heroes ... for EVERY day!
greyfin10 wrote:
I liked that part as well but his vocals and the tempo just didn't capture the original spirit of the song, IMO.
Oh, I don't know. I think the string pattern in the background is pretty nifty.
I liked that part as well but his vocals and the tempo just didn't capture the original spirit of the song, IMO.
Ho^Hum
are you hearing this now? I'm still listening to the last song on my computer?
Oh, I don't know. I think the string pattern in the background is pretty nifty.
I've been a PG fan for nigh on 20 odd years and this one gets the big NOPE from me. BZZZZT. Keep the fabulous string arranger, but please try again.
Up to now, I've liked most of what Peter Gabriel does. But this. . .
"Mr Gabriel, you've gone from hero to zero. That song choice was terrible, the arrangement was atrocious and you're singing was horrible. At this stage I don't think you're going to survive the competition."
As for that twit peter_james_bond, he kind of likes it (but he has pitch control problems).
cayenne wrote:
I think he does a nice job with it. The other songs on the album I'm not sure yet, but as usual Bill and Rebecca find the good ones for us.
This is one of those songs that should not be covered. The original is perfect; everything else sucks in comparison.
I think he does a nice job with it. The other songs on the album I'm not sure yet, but as usual Bill and Rebecca find the good ones for us.
Like so many, I'm simply stunned by the complete and total awfulness of this. And I'm really a Peter Gabriel fan. Never thought I'd give him a 1, but he really earned it here.
Please, Bill, put this wretched mess to sleep!
Please, Bill, put this wretched mess to sleep!
It pains me to write this as I doubt there's a bigger PG fan, yet this version is painful to listen to; emotion is there, yet the execution is sorry.
This is one of those songs that should not be covered. The original is perfect; everything else sucks in comparison.
I usually really like Peter Gabriel but this album's not really doing anything for me apart from the string arrangements. I'd love to hear an instrumental version of it.
What is this? Now I need to listen to all of "So" just to get the bad taste out of my ears.
I couldn't believe that the entire album was this boring.
horstman wrote:
If you are not familiar with the original, you are probably very young or have been living in a cave.
I love Gabriel and this really is a terrible cover. Solid 1. What was he thinking. This song has such energy and he totally deflated it to boredom.
I'm plenty old enough to have partaken of the original.
It's just Bowie is like Citizen Kane for me. I know OF his being good, I just haven't gotten to it yet. Happens sometimes ya know?
If you are not familiar with the original, you are probably very young or have been living in a cave.
I love Gabriel and this really is a terrible cover. Solid 1. What was he thinking. This song has such energy and he totally deflated it to boredom.
I'm plenty old enough to have partaken of the original.
It's just Bowie is like Citizen Kane for me. I know OF his being good, I just haven't gotten to it yet. Happens sometimes ya know?
chirpie wrote:
If you are not familiar with the original, you are probably very young or have been living in a cave.
I love Gabriel and this really is a terrible cover. Solid 1. What was he thinking. This song has such energy and he totally deflated it to boredom.
Something tells me not being familiar with the original helps (Often does with covers)
7.
7.
If you are not familiar with the original, you are probably very young or have been living in a cave.
I love Gabriel and this really is a terrible cover. Solid 1. What was he thinking. This song has such energy and he totally deflated it to boredom.
sirdroseph wrote:
As a PG fan, I was going to give you hell for that comment, but unfortunately my opinion is not differing much from yours. Even Peter can't make this a good song. His cover of Listening Wind is my favorite from this album, so far.
Edit: At least it's better than The Wallflowers' version...
Yeah! I was amongst to give this a sucko barfo rating!! Admittedly I do not like Peter Gabriel, so I said that I was going to be fair and listen to the whole song from start to finish before rating and by God ol' Peter lived up to his image and this song did indeed suck As#!! Yay!
As a PG fan, I was going to give you hell for that comment, but unfortunately my opinion is not differing much from yours. Even Peter can't make this a good song. His cover of Listening Wind is my favorite from this album, so far.
Edit: At least it's better than The Wallflowers' version...
Something tells me not being familiar with the original helps (Often does with covers)
7.
7.
I think a simple dramatic reading - a la William Shatner would have been more compelling.
sirdroseph wrote:
1 from me.
Yeah! I was amongst to give this a sucko barfo rating!! Admittedly I do not like Peter Gabriel, so I said that I was going to be fair and listen to
I love Peter Gabriel, and this cover is AWFUL. WTF was he thinking.1 from me.
Yeah! I was amongst to give this a sucko barfo rating!! Admittedly I do not like Peter Gabriel, so I said that I was going to be fair and listen to the whole song from start to finish before rating and by God ol' Peter lived up to his image and this song did indeed suck As#!! Yay!
Very interesting. First that I've heard about this project, but I think I like it.
Droidac wrote:
Yeah, right. Nice way of putting it.
I think this is a cover that the world didn't really need.
Yeah, right. Nice way of putting it.
Commits the sin of going nowhere slowly. Has to have more going on than that to justify messing with the original.
Really not sure about this at all. I think I like his original material much better.
I think this is a cover that the world didn't really need.
Interesting and unusual.
There is generally not going to be much to make me yearn for David Bowie, but sadly, this does it.
Like the crispy string arrangement.
Not a compelling cover, imo.
I think I like his song selections better than his job of covering them. Too bad- I really wanted to like this stuff.
I know he's trying to put his own spin on a great song, but it is plainly a miss.
big love!
Interesting how many ratings before the song is even played out for the first time...
I'm just not sure you can touch this song without sounding much worse than the original.
ug, this is awful
Sweet!
...whoah - it's already out?!.
Slow start. After The Smiths it's a downer.
Does this guy think that he can take any song . . scratch that . . . some of the greatest songs ever . . . and make them better by giving them his dream sequence pace, no rhythm, droning voice and hyper orchestral backings? Come on.